[gmx-users] any alternative methods?

[Mark Abraham]

On 22/08/2012 3:34 PM, Albert wrote:
> On 08/21/2012 08:25 AM, Mark Abraham wrote:
>> Since that calculation is one of the main purposes of GridMAT, I'd 
>> suspect you're comparing two different quantities, or not calculating 
>> one correctly.
>>
>> Mark
>> -- 
>
> I am very curious about this. The initial ALP for my equilibrated POPC 
> system is something around 67 which is close to experimental data. I 
> use g_membed insert a 300aa into the membrane and I equilbirate the 
> system with 20,000 step minimization+ 0.6 ns NVT+40 NPT. All 
> simulation were performed with both latest Slipids FF and CHARMM36 FF. 
> But either forcefield can get a satisfied ALP for the membrane/lipids 
> system.

I don't see how this relates to your claim that you computed a value 
with GridMAT that doesn't relate to a value computed some other way.

Mark